Forgot to upload this one last week. Episode 5 coming in a few hours.
Refer to Episode 1 for staff list and notes.
We now have a public discord server for the index of anime releases that we maintain. Any questions related to the sheet or releases by affiliated groups can be asked in this server. Feedback is also appreciated.
Report any issues/leave feedback in the comments or in the discord server.
Comments - 19
herkz
fast
Ingenioussubs
fuck, herkz stole the first comment
herkz
owned
btw there’s some stuff on your google docs thing that are definitely wrong/weird (at least about commie releases since i have first-hand knowledge) but i don’t use discord so i can’t go there to complain. dunno how much you care though.
giftkrieg
@herkz like what?
SeaSmoke (uploader)
You can leave comments on the sheet itself in edit view
herkz
yeah but how would you know it’s me? it could be anyone.
anyway there’s stuff like this listed for chihayafuru
which couldn’t be more wrong. i also edited it very heavily and changed the poem translations quite a bit too so there’s no consistency with the old releases. the old subs were pretty bad, especially for season 1 since it aired before motion-tracking was even a thing. i would say MK should only be recommended for the dub, but the dub is very weird and i don’t even know if the sub track for the dub was done right.
as for DIVE!!, SCY-Kuromii’s releases uses outdated subs from the TV release, so commie should probably be listed as an alternative.
for haikyuu, some of the releases for season 2 and 3 use TV subs as well even though my BD release has tons of improvements. for instance for season 3 i fixed quite a lot of TL errors by referencing sentai’s BD subs since they did their own translation but it wasn’t released until a few years later.
sk8 is out of date, though maybe you just haven’t updated it yet. the BD release is dual audio too so no need to list lostyears anymore.
for the great passage, it says this
but that doesn’t really describe it. yes, i had to splice them in because they were separate files on the disc, but i did that to match the TV broadcast. they’re supposed to be there.
herkz
for Natsume Yujin-cho the Movie: Ephemeral Bond, APTA’s subs were pretty bad in terms of fansubbing (since they’re scanlators and have no idea what they’re doing) and also contained some TL errors (which you can read in the comment section on their uploads), so i’m not sure it’s wise to recommend a release that partially used their subs just for better video. or at least commie should be recommended as an alternative.
for tokyo godfathers, it’s not obvious from the screenshot comparison but the new US BD release stabilized the video, which is a pretty big improvement as even “static” signs had to be motion tracked in subs for the old BD. it might have a less grain, but i still think it’s better overall (and imo has more correct-looking colors). that’s not really about any release in particular though.
i could nitpick some other stuff, like the numerous dual audio releases that are recommended even though the signs weren’t edited to match the dub track at all since most of the people making them have no idea how to fansub, but i guess dub watchers don’t deserve good releases anyway :^)
Simplistic
toxic
vodka
Make google account with a @commiesubs.com email, comment on the sheet?
vikrant9760
Herkz I like your subs but why are you always so toxic man.
herkz
sorry i insulted dub watchers
vodka
we all know most of the dub watchers can’t read in the first place so at least you did not offend any of them directly
_K4FK4_
that goes for most anime watchers in general tbf
vikrant9760
@herkz which releases for Haikyuu use your TV subs? Did you check AC S1 and S2?
Id get yours but you never did S1 in 1080p.
iamnotlolicones
weebs smh
TheDevilsHyper
Heavy Driver
herkz
you can just check by the release date.
vikrant9760
Will do. Also any updates on Haikyuu S4 BDs?
herkz
they still haven’t been uploaded sadly